Investigating Committee

Annex 2 - Performance Feedback – Panel Members/Peer Review


Application of Relevant Legislation
- Demonstrated knowledge and understanding of the legal process
- Adhered to legal and procedural frameworks
- Understood advice offered by Legal Assessor
- Good at following guidelines/protocols




* Supportive comments required

Understands Committee Function in Public Protection and Fair Hearings
- Raised relevant public protection issues during deliberations
- Balanced public protection against other issues appropriately




* Supportive comments required

Works in a Collaborative and Professional Manner
- Treated all those involved in a hearing with respect.
Calm non-confrontational manner.
- Actively engaged throughout
- Listened to colleagues.
- Made every effort to understand different points of view.
- Behaved appropriately.




* Supportive comments required

Participates Effectively in the Decision Making Process
- Actively and constructively participated in decision making
- Provided reasons for own view; used evidence in a fair and objective way.
Considered balance of evidence without bias.
- Showed commitment to Committee’s decision regardless of personal views.
- Took legal advice into consideration in decision making




* Supportive comments required

Communication & Conduct During Hearings
- Listened attentively throughout.
- Took notes of points from written and oral evidence.
- Asked fair and relevant questions in plain language with non-intimidating manner
- Body language indicated attentiveness and neutral attitude
- Expressed themselves clearly and succinctly




* Supportive comments required