Skip to main content

For the 2023/24 CPD year, all registrants have to complete a focused reflection on equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI). relating to Standard A4 in The Code which requires chiropractors to “treat patients fairly and without discrimination and recognise diversity and individual choice’ and Standard D2 in the Code, which requires chiropractors to ‘…treat all patients with equal respect and dignity’.

Tips on reflecting on EDI

At a new graduate introduction to CPD event in January, chiropractor Philippa Oakley shared her tips for reflecting on EDI as part of your CPD.

Public and Registrant attitudes to Equality, Diversity and Inclusion

In Summer 2023, we carried out a survey of registrants, and a similar survey of patients, to understand their experiences of discrimination within the profession and their attitudes to equality, diversity and inclusion. In total, 562 registrants completed the survey and 510 patients completed the survey:

Useful information

Scenarios

To help you reflect on EDI and how it could affect your clinical practice, we have prepared the following real-life scenarios for you to consider. These have been shared in the monthly newsletter and on LinkedIn, and we have asked Philippa Oakley - a chiropractor and consultant on Equality, Diversity and Inclusion - for her suggestions of what to consider.

The suggestions are not comprehensive - there may be other approaches that are equally as valid, and the key in many of these scenarios is having a conversation with the patient to come to a solution that respects their life experience and health goals, with your clinical expertise and knowledge.

A lesbian couple enjoy a glass of wine. The banner across the top reads: 'My wife and I have never needed a smear test'

Scenario 1 - "I hate translating for my mum..."

A patient comes to see you having recently moved to the UK from abroad, she does not speak English and brings her 14-year-old daughter with her to act as interpreter. During the course of the treatment, the daughter says to you “I hate interpreting for my mum. I dont always know the right words in English so I just make it up.”

Some questions for you to consider:

  1. How can you ensure you are receiving (and giving) accurate information in this encounter?
  2. What safeguarding concerns might you have for the daughter in this situation?
  3. What areas of the GCC Code do you need to consider in this scenario?

Seek professional interpreter or ask if another family member can come in.

Safeguarding concerns about care responsibility for the child and the accuracy of medical information - also is child being forced to take on adult responsibilities, dealing with sensitive information about the parent that they may not otherwise be privy to, and under additional stress from these responsibilities.

GCC Responsibilities:

  • Standard C1 “obtain and document the case history of each patient, using suitable methods to draw out the necessary information”
  • Standard E1 “you must share with the patient accurate, relevant and clear information to enable the patient to make informed decision about their health needs and relevant options. You must also take into consideration a patient’s capacity to understand.”

An interesting article on this is available here: https://www.dynamiclanguage.com/the-dangers-of-using-children-as-their-parents-interpreters/

A lesbian couple enjoy a glass of wine. The banner across the top reads: 'My wife and I have never needed a smear test'

Scenario 2 - "Can I take my hearing aids out?"

A 75-year-old patient presents to your clinic. He has been profoundly deaf since birth and wears hearing aids bilaterally. He brings several pages of health documentation with him which has branded him a ‘poor historian’, and most of his medical records include written notes from the patient or his daughter.

  1. What should you be aware of when caring for a patient with hearing aids?
  2. What are your responsibilities in regard to an interpreter?
  3. It is tempting in these scenarios to speak loudly and slowly to convey information via lip reading and volume. What are the potential problems here, and how can these be addressed?

  • Hearing aids are not a perfect solution and the patient may still face challenges in certain environments. If you require the patient to remove the hearing aids at any point, ensure you clearly communicate any instructions or information beforehand.
  • Be aware that many patients with progressive hearing loss have got used to ‘passing’ as hearing, and can be very convincing in showing they have understood information- such as by nodding and responding during pauses in the conversation. It can be helpful to provide written information to these patients as well to ensure they have full understanding.
  • You are not legally obligated to provide an interpreter, but there are companies that can provide an online-based interpretation service if required.
  • Speaking loudly and slowly does not necessarily enhance understanding for patients with hearing loss as it can distort lip-reading cues and may not improve comprehension- in addition it may appear condescending and stigmatising.

A lesbian couple enjoy a glass of wine. The banner across the top reads: 'My wife and I have never needed a smear test'

Scenario 3 - "Don't tell me to calm down"

Three weeks ago, you discharged a patient from care at your clinic after they behaved aggressively towards your receptionist when they were unable to offer the patient an appointment at a quieter time of day. In their complaint, the patient states that their behaviour can be attributed to their medical conditions, having been recently diagnosed with a mental health condition that has become so severe they have had to stop work. They believe that you have discriminated against them.

  1. What are your legal responsibilities in relation to this patient?
  2. Think about your understanding of discrimination in relation to mental health. What is your understanding? How could you have handled this situation differently?
  3. What reasonable adjustments could you/should you make to accommodate this patient’s needs in the future?

  • You have a responsibility to discharge the patient with signposting to another care provider and should carefully document your reasons for discharging the patient from your cre.
  • The decision to discharge the patient should be done carefully and in accordance with guidance from your insurers, and potentially with legal advice too. In this situation, it appears not to be a decision based solely on a mental health diagnosis but rather on a thorough assessment of the patient’s behaviour and its impact on staff and other patients.
  • Standard C6 of the code requires you to “cease care, or aspects of care, if this is requested by the patient or if, in your professional judgement, the care will not be effective, or if, on review, it is in the patients best interest to stop. You must refer the patient to another healthcare professional where it is in their best interests.”
  • Remember- if a mental health disorder if severe enough to impact ADL’s (activities of daily living) then it is likely considered a disability and as such will be a protected characteristic and grounds for discrimination. You could also refer a patient back to their GP (or similar) for a review of their mental health concerns if the patient feels these are not being well-managed currently.
  • Reasonable adjustments - consider offering the patient appointments during a less intense practice environment and ensuring these are scheduled far enough in advance that you have availability to do so. This may require more availability for ‘quiet’ appointments.

A lesbian couple enjoy a glass of wine. The banner across the top reads: 'My wife and I have never needed a smear test'

Scenario 4 - "My wife and I have never needed a smear test"

A 48-year-old (cis)woman attends your clinic with pelvic pain. She loves socialising at the pub with her wife, but is now finding sitting on the bar stools uncomfortable. She records in her documentation that she has a past medical history of hypertension, depression, and a family history of cervical cancer. She tells you that she is taking antidepressants.

  1. What clinical concerns should you have in relation to her family history of cervical cancer?
  2. Why should cervical screening be a particular concern for you in relation to the care of lesbian and bisexual women?

  • A family history of cervical cancer may indicate genetic predispositions or shared environmental factors that could increase the risk of developing cervical cancer. Have any known genetic factors been identified such as mutations in genes BRCA1 or BRCA2?
  • Women with a family history of cancer may need to be more vigilant with cervical screening.
  • Studies show that there is widespread underutilisation of cervical screening in the LGBTQ+ community- possibly due to misconceptions about risk, discrimination, stigma, lack of awareness or assumptions about low-risk sexual behaviours.

A lesbian couple enjoy a glass of wine. The banner across the top reads: 'My wife and I have never needed a smear test'

Scenario 5 - "The pain distracts me from being close to Allah ('azza wa jall)"

 A 66-year-old male Muslim patient presents to you with bilateral knee osteoarthritis identified on plain film imaging at his local hospital. His consultant has recommended that he consider knee replacement surgery to help resolve his symptoms, but he is keen for more immediate support during the upcoming holy month when prayer increases. He is finding Sajdah (the low kneeling bow in the direction of Mecca during Muslim prayer) increasingly difficult and painful.

  1. What are the biomechanics of sajdah and its impact on the anatomy of the knee?
  2. What lifestyle modifications would you suggest for this patient, and how would you help progress their home exercise programme to increase their ability to tolerate movements of prayer, reduce knee pain and limit OA progression?
  3. Would you feel confident advising modifications to a prayer position or technique and how you could do so in a culturally sensitive manner?

  • Incorporate guidance on mechanics of sajdah and discuss with patient how this can be adapted to incorporate better mechanics of the knee.
  • Lifestyle modifications - address any weight loss concerns and underlying deficiencies from any dietary imbalances that could be contributing to knee pain. If the patient is taking pain medications, can the timing of these be adjusted to optimise pain control during periods of increased activity, such as before prayer times.
  • It would not be inappropriate to suggest to the patient that they consider modification of prayer position - speak to their religious leader, speak to the patient, advise patient of use of a support and or/pillow under the knees or under the mat to provide some cushioning.

Scenario 6 - "I had a great break - but I overdid the hiking!"

A 33-year-old black male patient, who you regularly treat, attends your clinic after his first walking holiday in a UK national park. He shares with you how much he enjoyed his break, but says he is "feeling it now" with muscle pain and headaches - which he puts down to carrying his heavy rucksack for long periods of time. He's also beginning to notice symptoms of tingling and pain in his arms and legs.

  1. What adjustments to his rucksack and equipment would you suggest to prevent further problems the next time he goes hiking?
  2. What are the symptoms of Lyme disease and why would his clinical history suggest an increased risk?
  3. What would you expect a Lyme disease rash to look like on black or brown skin?
  4. How, where and when should you refer your patient for diagnosis and further treatment?

  • Ensuring that all straps on the backpack are utilised, in addition to wearing the straps on both shoulders. Positioning the rucksack so it sits higher on the back can avoid extension through the lower back, and ensure that heavy items are packed at the bottom of the bag to help with weight distribution.
  • Symptoms of Lyme disease (Erythema Migrans) can vary but chiropractors should always consider this in a patient with a history of recent travel to areas where Lyme disease is commonly found, including moors and heathland, and some woodland. Other symptoms may include fever, rash, intermittent flu-like symptoms, joint pains, and sometimes a bullseye rash.
  • On darker skin, a lyme rash can look like a bruise, the edges may feel slightly raised.
  • As Lyme disease can be easily misdiagnosed in people with black or brown skin, it is not uncommon for them to present with more advanced pathology. As such, an urgent referral should be made to the patients GP or, if presenting with more advanced neurological findings, the patient should be sent to your local emergency department.

Scenario 7 - "Sorry Luv - I don't think you are going to be strong enough to adjust me..."

You work in a small clinic and are planning a month-long holiday of a lifetime. During your break your associate, a female chiropractor in her late 20’s, is going to be covering your patients as well as her own for the month.
After his appointment one of your regular patients, a 34-year-old male rugby player, is booking his next maintenance visit – which happens to be during your holiday. Your colleague walks through the reception so you introduce them to each other. He comments: “Sorry luv, no offence, but I’m not sure you’re going to be strong enough to adjust me”.

  1. How would you respond to this comment?
  2. Would you respond differently if, instead of being said in front of your associate, the comment was made directly to you by email?
  3. What support could you offer to your associate to prevent a similar scenario occurring in the future?
  4. Is your associate within their rights to refuse to treat the patient?

An interesting one and sadly all too common…

  • “Adjustments are about speed and specificity, not strength. Chiropractors learn how to adjust people of all shapes and sizes effectively. Now let’s get going, shall we?”
  • No. I may provide more detail and/or citations if necessary, but the information remains true regardless of the manner of communication.
  • Equipping team members with “stock phrases” to fall back on can be helpful, particularly for new grads. This can be useful for those “mind went blank” moments where you forget everything you’d like to say in the moment! If the associate DOES have concerns about adjustments, offering advice and clinical pearls to help them leverage their body weight more effectively can be beneficial.
  • No, there are no serious grounds I could think of to refuse to treat. However, the associate needs to feel confident that their treatment is truly effective for that patient and so if they have doubts that they can provide effective interventions (for any reason) they could consider referring to another practitioner, co-management or changing their plan of management.

Scenario 8 - "I can solve this in under four minutes"

Your new patient is the 15-year-old son of one of your regulars.
You and his mum have discussed him during her appointments so you know he is autistic, but is doing well at a mainstream school. You also know he is heavily into his judo, and he has injured his back landing badly after he was thrown by a less experienced player.
When you walk into the waiting room he is sat next to his mum, wearing a tight polo neck jumper. He is staring intently at a 5x5 Rubik’s cube, then out of the blue says: "I can solve this in under four minutes".

  1. What considerations might you need to explore with your patient to understand his experience of autism? 
  2. What allowances or accommodations might you need to make to your practise to account for his needs?
  3. Are there any clinical concerns you should consider in relation to his autism?
  4. Will you involve his mother in the appointment? And if so, in what capacity?

  • Recognise and understand some of the common indicators of autism and how these might present themselves in clinic - for example literal interpretation of language, dislike of small talk and being less likely to initiate or reciprocate in a two-way conversation can affect the clinician’s interaction with that patient. Building awareness and understanding of that patient’s individual experiences and how they prefer to be interacted with can help minimise distress (if any) to the patient.
  • More time may need to be given to ensure they have understood instructions and have their questions answered. People with autism may experience higher anxiety when going into new situations and, coupled with hypersensitivity in any sensory modality can mean that examination, ROF and treatment need to be spread over several treatments in order to fully support this patient.
  • Clinical concerns about autism mostly link towards understanding and ensuring that they are capable of consent - they may not pick up on non-verbal cues and may take language very literally which may cause challenges. There are also a number of other common co-occurring conditions that are relevant, and difficult clinician-patient relationships may affect clinicians' interactions with patients, including reduced motivation to spend time with that patient.
  • The mother should be involved as the child is only aged 15, however, he may be able to grant consent himself if it is believed he has the intelligence, competence and understanding to appreciate the treatment plan. The mother could also be helpful in ensuring the patient complies with their treatment plan and supporting the young teenager on their journey to recovery.

Scenario 9 - "It’s the one I’m missing that’s causing me grief!”

A 35 year old military veteran mentions that his prosthetic leg is causing him some pain, and he reports some discomfort into his sacroiliac region.
On examination, you identify restriction in the base of the lumbar spine and some issues with the fit of his prosthesis. 

  1. What modifications would you need to make to treat this patient effectively?
  2. How well do you understand the process of prosthetic fittings, and the likely issues patients may encounter?
  3. What, if any, considerations would you need to be aware of when caring for a military veteran? How can you give particular consideration to trauma, mental health and their likely impact on outcomes from care?

  • Treatment may need to be modified to ensure the patient can easily access your treatment room. Other adaptations may be incorporating different soft tissue management of the remaining limbs, evaluating for leg length discrepancy, being aware of pressure points within the socket and other clinical considerations such as pressure sores, phantom limb pain and mechanical wear and tear.
  • Prosthetic fittings are a long process with an initial fitting, dynamic fitting and then repeated follow up treatments for alterations and adjustments. The type of prosthesis, its purpose, design and manufacturing system will all affect how well the patient copes with it. This type of issue should be co-managed with the prosthetics team.
  • Military veterans may suffer from PTSD which can affect their response to pain and treatment. This could be accompanied by depression and anxiety which will affect the patient’s motivation. An interdisciplinary team approach is best whereby clinicians can collaborate with other healthcare professionals, social workers and support teams.

Scenario 10 - "I'm not different to the other mums”

Stacey is a healthy 25-year-old woman who is 20 weeks pregnant with her first child - a baby boy. She is experiencing some lower back pain as a result of her pregnancy, and has sought your help after another mum at her antenatal class recommended chiropractic care.

Stacey has learning disabilities and lives in a supported living complex with her partner. She confides with you during your consultation that she feels that the midwife leading the antenatal class at her local GP surgery doesn't treat her the same as the other mums because of her learning disability.

  1. What modifications would you need to make to your care to account for her pregnancy?
  2. How can you ensure that Stacey understands any treatment you are proposing and any risks of that treatment in order to give her full consent to care? How will you record her consent?
  3. What methods of pain relief can you suggest to her that will account for her needs and relieve her back pain?
  4. Do you have any responsibility to update anyone else involved in her care (social worker, GP, midwife) around her seeking treatment? What would be the process if you felt this was appropriate?

This scenario is inspired by a case study from Healthtalk.org.

Modification of techniques to ensure they’re appropriate for a pregnant patient are clearly important here, along with optimising comfort and positioning throughout her pregnancy.

  • To ensure the patient is able to understand and give consent, clear and simple communication is vital, along with explaining each step of the process with demonstrations of any techniques or adjustments to be used can help the patient build an understanding of what to expect. Utilising a method such as the TeachBack method could help ensure the patient fully comprehends what has been explained along with robust documentation of consent within the medical records. Consent should be recorded in written format given at the time consent was sought, this can also be supported with additional records noting that verbal consent has also been given.
  • Ice or heat therapy are both appropriate in this case, along with gentle exercises. Supporting the patient with guidance on lifestyle modifications may also be useful, this could be given in the form of a visual aid, video, photos or advice leaflet/email which can help the patient build their understanding of their condition.
  • The GCC code Principle F requires chiropractors to “communicate properly and effectively with patients, colleagues and other healthcare professionals. This would indicate that yes, the involvement of the social worker and/or GP would be helpful- provided the patient provides written consent for you to do so. This could help with coordinating care and ensuring her treatment notes are fully contemporaneous. If the patient granted their consent for medical records to be released, the normal process within your clinic should be followed, and a letter to the patient should also be sent.

Focused Reflection on Candour (CPD 2024-2025)

For the Continuing Professional Development (CPD) year beginning on 1 September 2024 and ending on 31 August 2025, all registrants are required to complete a focused reflection on professional candour.

Find out More